The Ultimate Hot Leftover Turkey Sandwich and Gravy

How this sandwich helps speed up your Thanksgiving clean-up

Ok, Thanksgiving leftovers are my guilty treat. If I’m not dipping into the bag of yummy dishes sent home with me by my sister, I’m literally cooking my own turkey so that I can enjoy fresh turkey sandwiches, turkey pot pie, turkey soup, and my ultimate hot leftover turkey sandwich.
Let me explain why my hot leftover turkey sandwich is so craveable and something you’ll want to consider as you put away your leftover turkey.
First, you start to make it as you clean up Thanksgiving. Yep!
You put any scraps of turkey into a slow cooker base. Save the slices you want for cold sandwiches, and put the rest into the slow cooker.
Then add the leftover gravy into the same pot. Store it like that in the fridge. If you do this, your turkey disappears and in its place is your pot of turkey and gravy.
The next day, begin heating up the turkey a couple of hours before you want to eat. Check the stock and use the tip my Mom shared. Add a bit of stock to the mixture to thin out the gravy. You don’t want it too thick. Serve over thick-cut toasted bread. Yum!
Today, I love to amp up her classic version with a warm base layer of stuffing and cranberry sauce on top.
Here’s another reason why it is the ultimate:
When you are tired of these sandwiches, the base is perfect to add to your turkey soup, or mix with veggies and put into a turkey pot pie.
Why this recipe for the ultimate leftover turkey sandwich works
The gravy is never gloppy (technical word): Even the thickest pasty gravy works with this because you thin it out with chicken or leftover turkey stock. It makes it much lighter and soaks into the toasted bread.
Thick-Cut Toast Holds Its Crunch: Using sturdy, 3/4-inch to 1-inch slices of toasted bread is perfect to absorb the gravy while staying together so you can cut it with a fork and knife.
Built-In Cleanup and Crowd-Ready Prep: Tucking your leftover cooked turkey and gravy directly into your slow cooker pot while you clean up saves refrigerator space and preps for the next day (that anyone can pull together).
Here’s a tip:
As you clean up your turkey after Thanksgiving Dinner, throw the bones into the freezer if you have space. This cuts down on the pressure to make turkey soup right away. Then you can pull them out when you are ready to make your favorite version of turkey soup.
The secret to the perfect gravy and why thick toast matters.
You know how horrible gravy is the next day. It thickens up because of the starches and natural gelatin from the turkey juices. Even heating that up and pouring it on a sandwich makes the whole thing heavy.
By whisking in warm chicken or leftover turkey stock over gentle heat, you end up with a lighter gravy that can soak into the leftover turkey and the toast once you pour it over.
Speaking of toast, regular bread just can’t hold up to the meat and the gravy. It breaks apart too easily. I recommend getting a whole, uncut loaf at the bakery section of your grocery store, and slicing it about an inch thick. After you toast it, the gravy can seep in just enough to soften parts of the bread, but you also have crunchy bits.
Tools & Equipment Needed
If you click on one and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps me keep the site ad-free, helping you focus on the content you came for!
Toaster
Ladle
Troubleshooting Guide
Common Issue | Cause | Easy Fix |
The gravy still feels too thick or pasty after heating. | Cold starches and gelatin absorb liquid as they warm up. | Whisk in more chicken or leftover turkey stock a little at a time until the gravy flows smoothly off a spoon. |
The toast turns soggy before you finish eating. | The bread slices were cut too thinly or toasted too lightly. | Slice your bread at least 3/4-inch thick and toast until deeply golden brown and crisp across the entire surface. |
The reheated turkey turns stringy or dry. | The gravy boiled rapidly, tightening the turkey muscle fibers. | Use the Cook setting on your slow cooker to begin the heating process and then turn it to low once things are heated. Then you can let it sit. |
Substitutions & Variations
Switch Up the Bread: Swap rustic sourdough for thick-cut brioche, Texas toast, or seeded whole-grain bread.
Use Leftover Roast Chicken: If you don't have turkey on hand, shredded or sliced roast chicken works just as well. Great for a weeknight dinner.
Add Crispy Bacon or Melted Cheese: Layer two slices of bacon over the turkey, or top with a slice of sharp cheddar cheese or Gruyère under the broiler for 1 minute before ladling on the gravy. OMG! Yum.
Skip or Swap the Toppings: Leave off the stuffing for a lighter sandwich (still my usual go-to), or trade cranberry sauce for a spoonful of pickled red onions for tangy brightness.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why should I thin leftover gravy?
Chilled gravy thickens significantly in the refrigerator as starches and natural gelatin firm up. Whisking in a splash of Chicken Stock or Leftover Turkey Stock makes it thinner and allows the turkey to absorb it while also soaking into the toast.
.
How do I prep hot leftover turkey sandwiches ahead of time for a holiday weekend crowd?
While cleaning up after dinner, place your leftover turkey, gravy, and 1/2 cup chicken stock or leftover turkey stock directly into the removable ceramic insert of your slow cooker, cover, and refrigerate overnight. About 2 hours before lunch the next day, place the insert into the slow cooker base on Cook until steaming hot, then switch to Warm or Low so guests can assemble fresh sandwiches on demand.
Can I freeze leftover turkey and gravy together for future sandwiches?
Yes, freezing the turkey in the gravy is one of the best ways to keep the meat tender. Pack the cooled mixture into airtight, portion-sized freezer containers for up to 3 months, thaw overnight in the refrigerator, and reheat gently on the stovetop with a splash of chicken stock.
What is the best bread to use for a hot open-faced turkey sandwich?
A sturdy, tightly crumbed loaf such as country bread, sourdough, rustic Italian bread, or you could even use small rounds of French bread.
Your next step in the kitchen
Pull out your slow cooker if you aren’t using it for anything else so it is ready for the turkey and gravy. If you are using your slow cooker to keep your side dishes warm, as I often recommend, then have a big bowl ready and put everything in there to store for your hot leftover turkey sandwiches the next day.
Additional Resources: After sandwiches, consider making Turkey Soup
Here's my recipe for the ultimate hot leftover turkey sandwich
Before you go...
If you haven't yet subscribed: Here is the link to subscribe to my free newsletter where you get tips like this and some recipes for inspiration.
Need help planning for Thanksgiving?
I've written a mini cookbook and guide to help you plan and prepare your Thanksgiving Dinner. Complete with our family recipes, shopping lists, cooking timeline, and tips, it will be your go-to resource year after year.
Only available from October - November, get yours today (or get on the waiting list)





Comments