What to Make vs. Buy for Thanksgiving
Why the "From Scratch" Trap Can Ruin the Meal
If you walked past the bakery I ran for years at 4:00 AM on the day before Thanksgiving, you would have been in holiday bliss.
The front display glowed softly against the morning dark. The windows were steamed up, and the air smelled like baking bread, cinnamon, apples, and butter. Actually, it is one of my favorite memories.
From the sidewalk, it looked like a scene straight out of a Hallmark movie.
Inside the kitchen doors, it was a completely different story.
The day before Thanksgiving was, hands down, the busiest day of our entire year.
Why?
Because virtually everyone eats the exact same meal on the exact same day. That meant hundreds of scratch-baked dinner rolls, baguettes, apple and pumpkin pies, not to mention breakfast pastries, had to be boxed, labeled, and staged for customer pickup by precisely 8:00 AM.
Pie orders were stacked ten deep on the cooling racks. Sheet pans lined every horizontal surface. The mixers ran nonstop.
What looked like effortless holiday magic from the street was actually the result of three solid weeks of logistical planning, four days of round-the-clock ingredient prep, and hundreds of collective hours on our feet in front of 400°F ovens.
Which brings me to an essential truth every holiday host needs to hear:
You do not have the time—or the staff—to be a full-time commercial bakery on Thanksgiving.
The trophy nobody is handing out
Somewhere along the way, you started to think that being a gracious host means making everything from scratch.
It's as if buying something premade is an admission of defeat. Let's burst that bubble right now!
Nobody hands you a trophy for baking the ultimate pie from scratch. Your guests will not examine your pie crust to see if it was handmade or store-bought.
They do not care whether your cranberry sauce simmered on the stove for four hours, or if you picked up a simple base and "doctored it up"—as my Dad used to say.
What do your guests actually notice?
They notice when you are sitting at the dinner table laughing with them, sharing stories, and enjoying the celebration.
When you try to do everything, you end up enjoying nothing.
Let’s look at three things you can do this Thanksgiving to reduce your stress.
My easy Cranberry Sauce Recipe (Jump to the recipe)
What to make vs. buy for Thanksgiving: The Rule of Three
Bakeries don’t churn the butter, harvest the grain, or mill the flour. They focus their energy strictly on the signature items that everyone enjoys—and they strategically source or delegate everything else.
In kitchen operations, that isn't cutting corners. That's smart resource management.
When deciding what to make vs. buy for Thanksgiving, I recommend using a simple framework I call The Rule of Three.
Pick two or three family favorite or specialty dishes to make from scratch.
Buy or delegate the rest.
What to make from scratch
Only make items that meet two criteria from scratch:
The Emotional Centerpieces: The dishes that carry deep tradition or family nostalgia (dressing is the one in our house, and probably the mashed potatoes).
The Recipes You Truly Love Making: The dishes that bring you the most joy to make. For me, I’m the dessert person. I LOVE making apple and pumpkin pies. Here’s the irony. My family doesn’t like desserts. Because I love making them so much, I make them for friends rather than family. I still get the same joy and satisfaction.
Limit yourself strictly to three. These get your prime oven space, your best ingredients, and your dedicated attention.
What to buy or delegate
For the rest of the table, take advantage of smart store-bought Thanksgiving hacks:
Dinner Rolls: Support a local bakery and pick up fresh rolls the day before. Reheat them in a basket lined with a clean cloth napkin. One year, I was determined to make rolls that I saw a television chef make. They ended up being delicious, but they literally took all day to make. Not worth the effort for a simple dish that no one really ate.
Secondary Desserts: If you love baking your signature apple crisp from scratch, buy the pumpkin pie from a trusted local bakery. Believe me, you will feel so much better. If you want something special, maybe purchase something you wouldn’t make, like pumpkin cheesecake, and surprise everyone.
The Appetizers: Skip elaborate hot hors d'oeuvres that require time and oven space. Set out a board with Marcona almonds, marinated olives, quality crackers, and a wedge of sharp cheddar. It is perfect for the pre-meal nibbles. My sister has also just set out big bowls of differently spiced homemade popcorn. It was delicious and not too filling.
Prep Work: Buy pre-washed greens, peeled butternut squash, and trimmed green beans. You are trading a few extra dollars to buy back your time and energy.
The high-impact shortcut: 10-Minute Spiced Cranberry-Orange Chutney
When you stop trying to make every complex dish from scratch, you free up the bandwidth to add simple but delicious surprises.
Fresh cranberry sauce is one of the easiest ways to prove that great food doesn't require hours of kitchen labor. It takes ten minutes, costs very little, and outshines canned jelly every single time.
Here’s the Recipe
Build your holiday cooking plan
Hosting a memorable holiday isn’t about proving how hard you can work. It’s about creating an environment where everyone—especially you—feels welcome and relaxed.
If you have my Thanksgiving Cookbook and Guide, I’ve outlined all the traditional recipes, provided shopping lists, and even timelines. You don’t have to follow the whole thing. Pick what works for you. Then use the cookbook to help you to build your holiday cooking plan. My hope is that it is easier for you with these resources rather than trying to juggle a bunch of internet, cookbook, and family recipes alongside AI.
What is your next step?
Take a look at your menu plan today. Decide on your three made-from-scratch dishes to help you figure out what to make vs. buy for Thanksgiving. Then plan where to buy the other items or who you can delegate them to. You never know; you may find Aunt Sally loves to make appetizers, so that comes off your list.
Next Step: Build your Thanksgiving Plan
Additional Resources: A collection of Thanksgiving Recipes to give you ideas.
Before you go...
If you haven't yet subscribed: Here is the link to subscribe to my free newsletter where you get tips like this and some recipes for inspiration.
Looking for a quick dinner tonight?
Three Minute Pantry Meals
These recipes are some of my go-to, last-minute meals I make right from my pantry. In just a couple of minutes, you too can have dinner on the table. Click on the button to download your copy now.
About Jen
Jen Vondenbrink is the creator of "Appetite for Life." With years of dedicated culinary experience and a passion for empowering home cooks, Jen translates intimidating kitchen techniques into accessible, everyday wisdom. Her recipes focus on mastering the "why" behind the cooking process, ensuring you build confidence with every dish while learning smart strategies to manage ingredients and minimize food waste.
Comments